Paris Report: August 2016

REGINA is an international Magazine with correspondents on the ground in more than a dozen countries. Today, REGINA’s Paris-based correspondent, 35, discusses the realities she is living today.

REGINA: What’s happening now?

PARIS: There have been so many controversies about the last two terror attacks: the one in Nice, and early this week, while he was celebrating mass, a priest who was held hostage by two Islamist terrorists who finally cut his throat and tried to kill the other people attending this weekday mass. And now, the French police blog has reported that in Belgium, a couple days ago, a priest was stabbed to death by a Syrian migrant. But no word of it in the big French media, of course. Would anger people even more.

REGINA: And what is your government saying?

PARIS: And the French president is saying all has been done to protect us against Islamist terror.

REGINA: How are French people receiving this?

PARIS: That’s like saying you citizens are potential targets and we, the country’s leaders, will not do anything but sit and watch it happen.

REGINA: And what are the people saying about this?

PARIS: A country’s leaders’ first duty is to protect the country’s citizens. Our leaders are so incompetent.

REGINA: What is the government response?

PARIS:  They’re saying things like, let’s understand our Muslim brothers who are “the first victims” of terrorism. No kidding?!  There’s no word to adequately describe the government’s attitude and rhetoric.

REGINA: One of the terrorists who beheaded the priest was under observation and had to wear a locator device, except for a few hours a day. It was during that time that he committed the atrocity. PARIS: The French government is only taking baby steps against terrorists. One of them in jail has been allowed a private cell with a private gym, because, so they say, he needs to be in good shape for his trial. Can you believe this? France is afraid of what the European Commission on Human Rights will say if it cracks down too hard on terrorists, on would-be terrorists, if they restrict freedoms too much for the sake of safety and security. Their philosophy right now is : better terrorists free to commit their crimes and thousands slaughtered than a few innocents surveilled or arrested by mistake.

REGINA: What do you think most French people are thinking, in their hearts?

PARIS: Those terrorists are France’s enemy, or traitors when they’re French and should be handled as such. But they’re not because Muslims can’t be stigmatized by France, in the name of Human Rights, but any of us, hundreds of us, honest non-Muslim citizens may be slaughtered, that’s okay.

REGINA: Hungary’s prime minister has state unequivocally that they do not need migrants. Are any other countries also taking a different stance?

PARIS: Poland could not care less about what that European commission says about their practices, for the better. But we, the French, drape ourselves in virtue and good conscience, so we can’t go against what the EU says we should do. Too bad if innocent citizens are killed because of that. The exception to this is the Corsicans. French leaders may be scared, but not in Corsica. There, the main organization for the independence of Corsica has publicly stated: if ISIS agents start killing Corsicans, we’ll do the same to them. Not to say that that’s the right thing to say and/or do. But many in France say well, at least they have guts.

REGINA: Where does the French Church stand in all of this?

PARIS: At the beginning of the current president’s Hollande’s term, four years ago, his minister of Education said Catholicism was threatening democracy in France. Today the French Catholic church is saying to its flock:  let’s love those who are  slaughtering us.

REGINA: Nothing else?

PARIS: No. Nothing like ‘this is just intolerable, awful, horrible, we are so damn mad, those terrorists are evil.’

REGINA: What do French Catholics in the pews think about what the Church hierarchy is saying?

PARIS:  The Pope least of all. Our priests, bishops and archbishops are offering us in sacrifice. That’s as simple as that.

REGINA: We hear the same thing.

PARIS: Okay, when you’re Christian, talking of love and peace makes sense even in the worse situations. But damn it, at least say something to condemn the evil and those who’re committing it, to say you understand your flock’s outrage. No. Nothing.

On TV, one priest even said we should consider forgiving. Really ? The Church will not allow the divorced and remarried to go to communion, for example, but as a terrorist, especially if you slaughter a priest, you may be forgiven, just like that? Plus, nobody has asked for forgiveness.

REGINA: We hear the same thing.

PARIS: But to be fair, I have read about one army chaplain and the bishop to the French armed forces who have said things to the effect that it’s never said in the Scriptures that Christ is against all violence. Accepting to be crucified is very violent. Christ has kicked the merchants out of the temple. Violence may be legitimate when you use it to defend yourself, your loved ones, your country. It has never been asked of Christians to offer themselves, their priests, their children in sacrifice to evil. But those who dare say such things are not the priests or bishops interviewed in the media.

REGINA: This morning, our Facebook friends reported, “Three police guarding a packed Mass in Cannes, France.” Have you seen this or heard this from anyone?

PARIS: Soldiers standing guard in front of churches is useless. Those terrorists do not care. Nothing will deter them from killing, taking their own lives or being killed and die as martyrs as they say.

REGINA: English-speaking media is blaring that Muslims are attending Catholic masses ‘in solidarity’ today. Have you seen this or heard this from anyone?

PARIS: On Sunday, imams invited Muslims to attend mass in solidarity with Catholics. Many people are not sure what to think of that. And then, they are doing that now, but did they express solidarity with the Jews when that Islamic terrorist entered a Jewish school in Paris and slaughtered children? Did they express solidarity when three French soldiers were shot down near their base? They did not.

REGINA: France has a huge Muslim population. Is no one speaking up about this travesty?

PARIS: On a radio (RMC) talk show, a listener called to say he was Muslim and as such was so mad at France’s being way too kind with the Islamic terrorists, that he’s sick and tired of terrorists being so well treated, that in Algeria or Morocco, they would be treated as the worst criminals. Hopefully, many Muslims think the same. We don’t know as there’s often what is said to the media, and what is really thought.

REGINA: What has the government done vis a vis stopping the spread of radical Islam?

PARIS: They say they have been closing mosques where radical imams are preaching. You know what? They close these mosques for some time, and then you learn in the press that the same mosques have been allowed to re-open. Yesterday, there was a meeting between the minister of the Interior and imams’ representatives: the latter promised for the umpteenth time to reform their practices. They have been promising that for years, but nothing has been done. And, say some specialists, they can’t change the Koran, anyway.

REGINA: What do you read into the actions of the current French government?

PARIS: Our leaders are scared of being labeled racists, anti-Muslims, extremists, politically incorrect, etc. Too bad if that kills thousands of citizens. Finally, there are people who say that it makes sense that the Church does want to make things worse by having harsh words on Islam or Muslims. The Church and the government are scared of one thing: that a clandestine organization will start acting against Muslims or even that there will be civil war.

Paris in Pain

Paris is a lovely woman, and she is in atrocious pain.  They are her children, these French Catholics, and REGINA readers. Eric Paunowitsch is 58 years old, living in the west of the 10th arrondissement of Paris, where last Friday’s attacks took place. Marie Rivière, 42, lives just outside Paris. Jean Lamotte, 45, is a … Read more

The Secret Catholic Insider Guide to France

Passion, Courage & Glory Paris, 2014. We are a couple of American journalists in a tiny Audi, prepared to part ways and head out of town. The SAT NAV assures us it will be 21 minutes to our hotel.   Almost three hours later, we arrive. The problem? Animal rights protesters — thousands of them, … Read more

Understanding Catholic France: A Conversation with a French Country Priest

By Harry Stevens France is a confusing place for outsiders, especially when they don’t speak French and they are trying to understand the position of the Catholic Church there. Thankfully, a chance encounter with an English-speaking country priest with a broad and deep education led Regina Magazine down a fascinating path. Here’s our interview with … Read more

Notre Dame’s Love: The History Of Marian Apparitions In France

 By Penny Silvers Of the fifteen apparitions of the Virgin Mary officially confirmed by the Holy See through the world, fully one third have occurred in France. The history of Marian apparitions in France begins in 1208. Until her last appearance in 1871, Mary appeared in turn to a Spanish friar in the south of France, … Read more

The Secret of Sainte Menehould

Today, it’s a boring town in the empty reaches of eastern France. Cheerless grey houses crowd the main road on the way in to town. The local specialty — served with Gallic pride — is pig’s trotters. But despite its mundane appearance, Sainte Menehould is not just an ordinary farm town. It is the place where … Read more

La Grande Journée

Penny Silvers takes Regina Magazine to Paris on La Grand Journée, in honor of the 800th birthday of the saintly and Most Christian King, Louis IX. Born in 1214, King Louis was crowned king at Reims Cathedral at the age of twelve. He ruled the Kingdom of France at the height of its great medieval … Read more

How the Black Death & the Best Wines Created ‘The House of God’ in Burgundy

Inside a Medieval Catholic Hospital for the Sick Poor By Harry Stevens At the close of the Hundred Years War, France was a devastated nation.  The French, particularly the poor, were at the meager mercy of marauding soldiers bent on destroying and plundering the countryside.  Though the 1435 Treaty of Arras had essentially brought the … Read more

Louis Speaks

He is twenty years old, and he has a few things to say about history, his country, his French culture and his ancient Faith. His name is Louis.    I grew up in Châtelaillon-plage, in Charente-Maritime on the Atlantic coast.   It is a small beach town and my family is a Catholic one.   … Read more